If you landed here from my Other Blog, thanks for clicking through. If you haven’t read that one, here’s my “prequel” post, which may amuse you. Basically, I waited a while to read Curtis Sittenfeld’s “American Wife,” and tore through it this weekend in one day.
It really is that good.
Here’s the summary: Just before the end of her husband’s second term as President of the United States, Alice Blackwell, nee Lindgren, reflects on and tells the story of her life, beginning with her childhood in Riley, Wisconsin, and finishing with her most recent activities. As many media sources have discussed, the novel is quite clearly an imagined telling of current First Lady Laura Bush’s life and times; in fact, that’s so clearly the case that the novel is prefaced with a note reading: “American Wife is a work of fiction loosely inspired by the life of an American first lady. Her husband, his parents, and certain prominent members of his administration are recognizable. All other characters in the novel are products of the author’s imagination, as are the incidents concerning them.”
However, I think the disclaimer should have read a little differently. Sittenfeld might have warned us all that this work of fiction can cause severe mental dislocation, convincing readers that they are actually sitting and reading in the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s. Each decade of Alice Blackwell’s life is rendered with such exquisite and accurate detail that time travel doesn’t seem out of the question.
This is important, because Sittenfeld has created a strong, consistent voice for her narrator, but without the chronological verisimilitude, Alice Blackwell’s reasoned locutions would fall absolutely flat. That is not a criticism. I believe that part of Sittenfeld’s genius as a novelist lies in her ability to balance tensions. Blackwell’s voice could not and should not be otherwise, but her convictions and actions would make less sense without context.
I would love t say that I savored this novel. Sittenfeld writes beautifully, and the book is full of the kinds of scenes you want to remember and share with other people, including a fascinating subplot reaching all the way to the final page that makes you rethink everything you’ve ever known about the First Lady upon whom the novel is based. However, I couldn’t stop reading.
Let me also say that I found the book terribly, terribly sad. I thought Alice Lindgren Blackwell’s choices were dictated not by wisdom and love, but by circumstance and circumscription. I wish Sittenfeld had been able to put a finer point on that aspect of her title character’s life; she tries to, especially in the early pages, but it gets lost in the examination of Alice and Charlie Blackwell’s marriage.
Here are links to some other reviews of American Wife:
In the New York Times, Joyce Carol Oates says that as a “portraitist in prose,” Sittenfeld is “not Francis Bacon but more Norman Rockwell.”
Meanwhile, Michiko Kakutani actually takes the opposite stance (what a surprise!), concluding that Sittenfeld uses the novel’s end to her own political purposes.
Susan Salter Reynolds of the LA Times thinks that the book has something in it for every American female.

1 Comment